Pettingill Analytics
Professional Recognition

Letters of Acknowledgement

Correspondence from trial attorneys across the United States recognizing Dr. Pettingill's expert witness testimony, forensic economic analysis, and contributions to landmark verdicts and settlements.

Robert B. Baker, Esq.

Baker & Zimmerman, P.A., Trial Attorneys — Boca Raton, Florida

Re: Sandra & George Imperatore v. Royal & SunAlliance Insurance Co.

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

I just wanted to inform you that we received a jury verdict late yesterday afternoon in the Imperatore case in which you provided testimony. I am proud to inform you that we hit a "home run". The jury returned a verdict of $338,000.00 on a case involving a torn ACL. The jury awarded all of the future medical bills reduced to present value based upon your extremely persuasive testimony.

On behalf of my client I wanted to thank you for your excellent work. We could not have done this without you!

Very truly yours,

Robert B. Baker

Verdict: $338,000

Robert B. Buchanan

Siboni, Hamer & Buchanan, P.A. — Ocala, Florida

Re: Orin Lee v. Gary Grooms, M.D.

Dear Mr. Pettingill:

Please allow this letter to serve as notice that the above-referenced matter has just been settled. Therefore, please discontinue all work and forward to us your bill so that we can place it in line for payment.

I would like to personally thank you for your cooperation and assistance, particularly upon such short notice. Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us.

Sincerely,

Robert B. Buchanan

Settlement reached

Keith M. Carter, Esquire

Gray Harris Robinson Shackleford Farrior — Tampa, Florida

Re: Goble v. Frohman

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

It was a pleasure working with you during the trial of the above-styled cause. We truly appreciate your attention to the herculean undertaking of evaluating plaintiff's business records and assessing his economic damages as a result of his injury. As you may recall, the plaintiff's expert opined that the plaintiff's economic damages exceeded $2.5 million. Fortunately, the jury completely accepted your economic analysis and rejected the analysis put forward by plaintiff's expert.

The jury verdict rendered in the above-referenced matter awarded $125,000 for loss of earning capacity and awarded $50,000 for past earnings. As you will see, the jury embraced your testimony and returned a verdict consistent with your findings and analysis. Truly, the result we achieved would not have been possible without your hard work, attention to detail and court room skills.

We hope to have the opportunity to work with you on future matters. We look forward to hearing from you soon.

Sincerely,

Keith M. Carter, Esquire

Verdict: $175,000 (plaintiff claimed $2.5M)

Scott R. Dwyer, Esq.

Scott R. Dwyer, P.A. — Melbourne, Florida

Re: Lea M. Urezzio v. Boyd & Kelly Mathews

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

I wanted to write to you to express my appreciation and that of my client, Lea Urezzio, for your assistance and testimony in her personal injury trial.

As you know, it has almost been 5 years since Lea was paralyzed in that automobile accident, and it was very gratifying to finally receive her day in court last month. I was very pleased with your testimony and the way you were able to present it to the jury in such a logical and understandable format. Many times expert testimony in the area of life care planning and economic present value is tedious and mundane. You presented it in a very interesting and understandable format which kept the jury attentive to all the evidence presented.

The jury was obviously very impressed with your credentials, presentation and information since they awarded the entirety of the economic damages claimed for by the plaintiff. The jury's total verdict of $13,800,000.00 is the largest personal injury verdict ever awarded by a jury in Brevard County, Florida. Needless to say, my client and I are very satisfied with the result and thankful for your assistance.

You did a great job and were crucial to our extraordinary success in this case. I look forward to working with you again in the future.

Sincerely,

Scott R. Dwyer, Esq.

Verdict: $13,800,000 — Largest PI verdict in Brevard County history

Rachel Alters

McGrane & Nosich, P.A. — Coral Gables, Florida

Re: Estate of Nancy Moya — Clients: Abdala Kalil, M.D. / Hialeah Emergency Medical Specialists

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

Please be advised the referenced matter has settled.

Accordingly, please forward any outstanding invoices you may have.

Thank you for your assistance. We look forward to working with you in the future.

Should you have any questions, please advise.

Very truly yours,

Rachel Alters

Settlement reached

William A. Norton

Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. — West Palm Beach, Florida

Re: Carroll case

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

Thank you very much for your excellent work in the Carroll case. Your economic loss calculations were very helpful in getting this case settled.

Thank you, again, for your help, and I look forward to working with you in the future.

Sincerely,

William A. Norton

Settlement reached

Eugene I. Pavalon

Pavalon, Gifford, Laatsch & Marino — Chicago, Illinois

Re: Letter to Members of The Inner Circle of Advocates — Medical malpractice settlement

Dear Friends:

The case described in the enclosed news clippings, which was settled on the day we were scheduled to begin trial, involved several matters which you may find of interest.

My client, a 30 year old single woman, on Social Security disability for years because of juvenile diabetes, chronic gastroparesis and depression was extremely vulnerable to life threatening infection and, therefore, it was especially important to obtain as early a trial setting as possible. I contacted Dr. Craig Lichtblau, a physiatrist of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida and Bernard Pettingill, a Ph.D. economist also of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida, who were identified in a letter Larry Grassini had sent to the Circle regarding their participation in his case, which resulted in a $51,000,000.00 verdict. Both were willing to address the relevant damage issues immediately and Dr. Lichtblau promptly flew to Chicago to examine the Plaintiff, photograph her and secure the necessary information concerning costs and services provided by local long-term life care facilities. Their prompt attention to the case helped us obtain a March 11th trial, which was only 10 months from the date we filed suit, which is most unusual for the Circuit Court of Cook County.

The Defendant, Louis A. Weiss Memorial Hospital's first layer of insurance was with St. Paul Insurance Company. I was not surprised that I experienced similar conduct from St. Paul which ignored this case until 3 weeks prior to trial, when it made its first offer of $3,000,000.00.

Two days before trial, I was called by Defendant's counsel and told that the Senior Vice President in charge of claims for St. Paul had been fired and a claims executive from Traveler's Insurance Company was hired to replace the fired Vice President. He flew to Chicago to engage in settlement negotiations two days before trial was to commence, which resulted in the settlement on the day of trial.

Sincerely,

Eugene I. Pavalon

Settlement on day of trial (initial offer: $3M) — Referenced $51M verdict

David C. Prather, Esquire

Lytal, Reiter, Clark, Fountain & Williams, Trial Lawyers LLP — West Palm Beach, Florida

Re: Isaac Hodges & Estate of Gladys Jackson

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

I wanted to write to thank you for the tremendous job that you did in not only working up the cases of Isaac Hodges and the Estate of Gladys Jackson, but also in testifying in Miami, as well as in Daytona Beach, Florida.

On both occasions, your testimony was critical regarding the economic losses sustained by Mr. Hodges, as well as the Estate of Gladys Jackson. Remarkably, I was able to obtain every penny of economic damages that were testified to by yourself. Not only did I receive all of the past economic damages, I also received all of the future economic damages on both cases which was substantial.

More importantly, the terrific job you did was reiterated by several of the jurors that approached me after each trial. It was a unanimous feeling that your testimony was the most exciting and most interesting. Moreover, the jurors were mesmerized by your presentation on such a technical subject as present money value.

Once again, I want to thank you for the terrific job that you have done for me on these cases, as well as the others in the past. The jurors always seem to love you and you seem to teach them in an exciting fashion. Hence, I will continue to utilize your services in the future due to your professional demeanor and your style in testifying on such a technical subject.

Very truly yours,

David C. Prather, Esquire

100% of economic damages awarded on both cases

Lyman H. Reynolds, Jr.

Roberts & Reynolds, P.A. — West Palm Beach, Florida

Re: Leigh S. Hayden

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

This letter is to advise you that this case has settled and we will not be proceeding with the case to trial next month. This letter will confirm that we have received your bills and they have all been paid.

We thank you for your time and assistance during the proceedings in this case and look forward to working with you in the future.

Sincerely,

Lyman H. Reynolds, Jr.

Settlement reached

Lee J. Rohn

Law Offices of Lee J. Rohn — Christiansted, St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands

Re: Constable v. Kmart

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

I just wanted to drop you a line to let you know what a great expert I think you are. As you know, the decision by the Court to vacate the $2.9 million dollar verdict in Constable v. Kmart was a set back. However, your superb testimony and quick adaptability to convert your opinion to a loss of services when the Court barred the vocationalist resulted in a second verdict of $3.4 million. I couldn't have done it without you.

Cordially,

Lee J. Rohn

Second verdict: $3,400,000 (after initial $2.9M vacated)

Marsha B. Wharin

McGrane & Nosich, P.A. — Coral Gables, Florida

Re: Arechavaleta v. Stegemoller, M.D.

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

Please be advised that this case has been resolved prior to trial. Thank you very much for your assistance. Please provide me with a copy of your latest invoice so that I can expedite payment.

Please don't hesitate to contact me should you have any questions.

Very truly yours,

Marsha B. Wharin

Resolved prior to trial

William S. Williams

Lytal, Reiter, Clark, Fountain & Williams, Trial Lawyers LLP — West Palm Beach, Florida

Re: Koenke v. Allstate Insurance Company

Dear Dr. Pettingill:

I just wanted to thank you for your testimony last week in the case of Koenke v. Allstate Insurance Company, wherein a jury awarded $1,896,000.00 to Tamara Koenke against Allstate Insurance Company.

Your testimony concerning the economic damages sustained to Tamara Koenke based upon the testimony of the vocational rehabilitation expert was excellent and was the best that I have seen in any of the cases that I have tried with you over the years.

I am very grateful to you concerning your well organized presentation in explaining the economic damages to the jury in a straight forward insightful manner.

Thank you once again.

Very truly yours,

William S. Williams

Verdict: $1,896,000

Considering Dr. Pettingill on your matter?

Engage Dr. Pettingill